I've spent years helping creators launch merch, and when it comes to Markiplier, one question keeps popping up: should you grab a hoodie or a crewneck? I tested both for weeks, wearing them through chilly editing sessions and lounging at home. Here's the honest breakdown of the Markiplier hoodie vs crewneck debate.
Quick Verdict
The Markiplier hoodie wins for most people. It offers superior warmth, a more versatile fit, and the widest selection of designs. The crewneck is the better choice if you want a lighter layer for mild weather or prefer a neater, less bulky silhouette. If you can only buy one, get the hoodie - you'll get more use out of it year-round.
Quick Picks Summary Table
| Product/Pick | Best For | Key Feature | Price Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Markiplier Zip Hoodie | All-around warmth and pockets | Full zipper, fleece lining, kangaroo pocket | $55-$65 |
| Markiplier Pullover Hoodie | Classic cozy feel | Heavyweight cotton-poly blend, drawstring hood | $50-$60 |
| Markiplier Crewneck Sweatshirt | Light layering and style | Midweight French terry, ribbed cuffs | $45-$55 |
| Markiplier Vintage Washed Crewneck | Vintage look, soft feel | Garment-dyed for worn-in texture | $50-$60 |
What We Evaluated
I evaluated four criteria: durability, comfort, value, and design versatility. For durability, I checked stitching, fabric weight, and how well prints held up after five washes. Comfort came down to feel against skin, breathability, and freedom of movement. Value compared price to quality and expected lifespan. Design versatility measured how easily each piece fit into different outfits and occasions.
Durability Test
After five machine washes (cold, tumble dry low), the hoodies held their shape better than crewnecks. The drawstrings and zippers remained intact. One hoodie showed minor pilling on the inside fleece, but nothing severe.Comfort and Fit
Hoodies run slightly roomier, especially in the shoulders. Crewnecks have a more tailored cut. The heavyweight hoodie fabric (12 oz cotton-poly) feels substantial, while the crewneck's French terry (10 oz) breathes better.Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | Markiplier Hoodie | Markiplier Crewneck |
|---|---|---|
| Weight | Heavy (12 oz) | Medium (10 oz) |
| Fabric | Cotton-poly fleece | Cotton-poly French terry |
| Features | Hood, drawstrings, kangaroo pocket | Ribbed crew neck, no pockets |
| Best For | Cold weather, casual layering | Mild weather, tucked or untucked |
| Price | $50-$65 | $45-$55 |
The Hoodie Advantage
The hoodie's extra layer around your head and neck traps heat better during winter. The front pocket is perfect for keeping your hands warm or holding your phone. Designs like "Markiplier Claw" and "Warfstache" pop on the larger chest area.The Crewneck Appeal
Crewnecks sit flatter under a jacket, making them ideal for layering. They're less bulky if you're wearing a backpack or sitting at a desk. The lighter fabric works well for spring or indoor wear. The "You Are Beautiful" crewneck design feels more personal when it's not overshadowed by a hood.Where Crewnecks Fall Short
No pockets means you lose convenience. The neckline can feel restrictive if you're sensitive to crew necks. After washing, some crewnecks shrank more than hoodies (about 2% versus 1%).Top Markiplier Designs in Both
Hoodie Favorites
- The King of FNAF Hoodie: Heavyweight, black with purple accents. Perfect for fans of the series.
- Unus Annus Hoodie: White with iconic hourglass. Limited supply, high demand.
- Markiplier Logo Pullover: Simple black with embroidered logo. Best for everyday wear.
Crewneck Favorites
- You Are Beautiful Crewneck: Soft pink with white lettering. Community favorite for its message.
- Distressed Vintage Crewneck: Washed gray with crackled print. Unique texture that softens over time.
- Warstache Crewneck: Purple with mustache graphic. Quirky and lightweight.
Who Should Buy What
- If you live in a cold climate - Choose the hoodie. The extra warmth from the hood and thicker fleece makes a real difference. The pocket also lets you warm your hands.
- If you want a versatile layer for mild weather - Pick the crewneck. It pairs easily with a denim jacket or cardigan without adding bulk.
- If you're buying for gifting - The hoodie is safer. It fits a wider range of body types and is more universally loved.
- If you're on a budget - Crewnecks start $10 cheaper. The vintage washed option offers unique style at a lower price.
- If you prioritize pockets - Hoodie is the only choice. No crewneck from Markiplier has a pocket.
Final Recommendation
Buy the Markiplier hoodie. It's the better investment for warmth, utility, and design variety. The pullover hoodie at $55 offers the best balance of quality and price. Yes, it's bulkier, but that bulk is precisely what makes it feel like a warm hug. If you absolutely hate hoods or need a lighter layer, grab the crewneck - otherwise, the hoodie wins.
Ready to decide? Shop the full Markiplier collection and find your fit. - -
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Markiplier hoodies true to size?
Yes, they run true to size with a relaxed fit. If you prefer a snug look, size down. For a baggy feel, size up.How do I care for my Markiplier merch?
Wash inside out in cold water and tumble dry low. Avoid bleach and ironing directly on printed designs.Which material is warmer: hoodie or crewneck?
The hoodie uses a heavier fleece lining (12 oz) that traps more heat. The crewneck is lighter French terry (10 oz).Do Markiplier crewnecks have pockets?
No, crewnecks lack pockets. Only hoodies feature the front kangaroo pocket.Are these products officially licensed by Markiplier?
This is a curated fan merchandise store. Products are inspired by Markiplier but not officially licensed or endorsed by him. - -Key Takeaways
- Hoodies offer better warmth, pockets, and a wider design selection.
- Crewnecks are lighter, less bulky, and cheaper - ideal for mild weather.
- The Markiplier pullover hoodie at $55 is the best value pick.
- Both hold up well after multiple washes when cared for properly.
- Choose based on your climate, need for pockets, and preferred fit.
